Problem objective tree is a method to analyze the problems that an organization or a community faces and to set up objectives to respond to these problems. Your tree trunk becomes your project objective, and the roots and branches are redefined to focus on solutions. Healthy work environment, recognize health and safety as priority, roll in prevention, improved working conditions through staff empowerment policies. The problems are converted through simple rewording into specific objectives, and the chart then shows a meansends relationship. Objective tree analysis the purpose of the objective tree is to identify specific objectives that will overcome each element of the problem tree. Problem and objective tree analysis measure evaluation. Problem tree 1a workshop at training centre, adats, 2325 feb 2004 revision no.
Project cycle management for international development. The problem tree analys is a commonly used tool in development projects. Using a problem tree analysis in project management. Then changing the wording of each item into positive terms will change the problem tree into an objective tree. Causes form the roots of the tree, the core problem is the trunk, and the consequences are the branches. Seven management and planning tools solution extends conceptdraw pro and conceptdraw mindmap with features, templates, samples and libraries of vector stencils for drawing management mind maps and diagrams. The first objective was to determine frequent and severe accidents in transportation infrastructure projects. Problem tree analysis sswm find tools for sustainable. You can use it both to analyze a new problem and as a tool to highlight the gaps in an existing problem. Draw an example of a problem tree based on the description given below and the example problem tree on the next page. The problem can be broken down into manageable and definable chunks.
Listing of possible solutions at an early planning stage easily hampers objective and openminded problem analysis. Project identification, formulation and design unit information 3 unit overview 3 unit aims 3 unit learning outcomes 3 key readings 4 further readings 5 references 5 1. Problem tree analysis is central to many forms of project planning and is well developed among development agencies. Problem tree analysis also called situational analysis or just problem analysis helps to find solutions by mapping out the anatomy of cause and effect around an issue in a similar way to a mind map, but with more structure. The problem tree highlights the relations and hierarchy among all identified problems. An example of a problem tree is shown below iucn, 1997 iii. Usually, a project focuses on one or a few core problems.
Here in a hypothetical example, we are assuming x country is facing of a problem around the limited use of evidence in policymaking. Defining the social problem necessities for impact. On another piece of flipchart paper, students create a solution tree, with output, outcome, and impact. Stakeholder analysis comparative table 18 figure 4.
Jan 30, 2015 work for ma in environmental sustainability at the university of dundee part of su21009 module. You may also find it useful to work upwards from the original problem, identifying its effect etc. Work for ma in environmental sustainability at the university of dundee part of su21009 module. For example, a cause problem tree such as lack of knowledge would become a meansoutputsfinancial incentives such as increased knowledge.
The statement at the summit of the tree the quality of life is improving is the longterm outcome or impact. Develop a solution tree a solution also called objectives tree is developed by reversing the negative statements that form the problem tree into positive ones. Problem tree analysis sometime called situational analysis or just problem analysis helps find solutions by mapping out the anatomy of the problem. A problem tree provides an overview of the known causes and effects of an identified problem. There is tendency to focus only on the problems that have been mentioned, other important problems are often ignored as a result. The trunk and the top of the tree often correspond to the levels of analysis in the socio. To formalize your project above and fill in the table annexed to the application form the matrix of the logical framework, you must identify the central problem of the action. Start by rewriting the main problem, as the outcome on the trunk. The problem tree is closely linked to the objectives tree, another key tool in the project planners repertoire, and well used by agencies. Objective of the group work to use a participatory methodology to understand the principal causes of malnutrition and how these are related to. To describe the future scenarios deriving from the problems solution. Linking up causes and consequences and getting a birdseyeview of the situation is one of the best advantage this problem analysis tool has to offer.
It provides a structure for the conversation that you. The problem tree, together with the objective tree and analysis of strategies, is a methodology of three steps for identifying main problems, along with their causes and effects, helping project planners to formulate clear and manageable objectives and the strategies of how to achieve them. A problem tree analysis is an excellent tool that can be used to identify and link up the causes leading to a problem and the consequences emanating from it. Define the problem, issue or object of the analysis with a group brainstorm. Decision trees work well in such conditions this is an ideal time for sensitivity analysis the old fashioned way. Using problem tree and objective tree to manage the big picture of problem. Problem and objective tree analysis introduction problem tree analysis is central to many forms of project planning and is well developed among development agencies. As you work through the roots and branches of your problem tree, overlaying each of them with solutions, you develop the framework that you need to. The objective of this approach is to analyze the root causes of an issue facing a community and to ensure the solution addresses the root cause. Problem trees and objective trees program cycle project. Problem tree poor health outcomes higher cost in long term decreased effectiveness sick hws bad workplace organization stigma and discrimination hws migration increase in hiv, hep b and c and other blood borne d.
This tool helps you to define where and where not to intervene. Problem tree analysis overseas development institute. Structure of problem tree analysis it is critical that existing issues are identified as well as future issues that may arise because of planned development, e. Write your focal problem in the middle of the space. Should be specific to one livelihood group the malnutrition problem tree is represented visually by a tree. The objective analysis tree is a tool derived from its parent tool the problem analysis tree. The third objective was to use fault tree analysis to study the relationships among the causes that were identified. The second objective was to identify the causes of the accidents. Now, rewrite the causes into positive outputs, and the negative.
The problem tree can be converted into an objectives tree by rephrasing each of the problems into positive desirable conditions as if the problem had already been solved and more. This preparatory work can be done by constructing a problem tree and an objective tree. This example provides an understanding of how the tool can be used, but by no means it is a complete analysis, because there would clearly be other causes and effects, and more links between solutions. Objectives tree summary determining a designs objectives is part of clarifying the design problem an objectives tree is a graphical way to show. Like any other tree, the problem tree has three parts. The relationship between the problems tree and the objective. Problem solution tree analysis is a tool which helps to understand complex challenges, and to find appropriate solutions by mapping out the cause and effect of each particular issue in detail.
The main output of the exercise is a treeshaped diagram in which the trunk represents the focal problem, the roots. Most simply this is done by reversing the problem factor, so, for example, low intake of ironrich foods is turned into highintake. Objective tree developmental objectives hws aware of safety and occupational health and of their rights project outcomes decent working conditions managers prioritize. The tree provides a visual structure for the analysis. This will give you a problem tree in which a cause and effect relationship operates from the bottom to the top. Your designs objectives the hierarchy of your objectives objectives are being words and express the attributes and behaviors expected by your client. Like the problem tree, the objective tree is a great tool to help you consider different perspectives, and to define the different routes that you could take to solve your problem.
It is anticipated that in most countries a problem analysis during project design and the development of an objective tree based on that analysis will. The problem tree is often followed by an objectives tree. Mar 03, 20 objectives tree summary determining a designs objectives is part of clarifying the design problem an objectives tree is a graphical way to show. The objective tree uses exactly the same structure as the problem tree, but with the problem statements negatives turned into objective statements positives ausaid, 2003. In this way, root causes and consequences are turned into root solutions, and key project or influencing entry. In defining a problem, it is important to differentiate between the problem itself, its causes and the. You may need anything from a couple ofhours, to half a day or more depending on thecomplexity of your problem and the diversityof stakeholders present. What is and how to make a problem tree issue tree season. An example of a problem analysis is shown in figure 7 with reference to channelization and disconnection of the floodplain.
The group will be divided into four small groups each group will draw a tree with roots, trunk and branches with leaves and fruits the roots of the tree will represent the causes of the problem that lead people toward hiv and aids all of these causes will pass thru the. Problem tree once complete, the problem tree represents a summary picture of the existing negative situation in many respects the problem analysis is the most critical stage of project planning, as then it guides all subsequent analysis and decisionmaking on priorities p. Using problem tree and objective tree to manage the big picture of problem duration. While the problem analysis tree is used for analyzing the current situation or a present problem, the objective analysis tree is utilized to analyze objectives, future situations and goals. Following the problem tree analysis, it is possible to rephrase each of the problems into positive desirable outcomes as if the problem had already been treated, the problem can be turned into an objectives tree.
For example, lack of sufficient water becomes improve water supply. The information necessary to create a problem tree arises from the data youve collected in the course of the needs assessment and context analysis the illustration on the left shows a problem tree for yea. It pushes you to deconstruct all possible causes for the problem rather than the obvious ones. The objective analysis tree basically converts the problematic. An objective tree is closely linked to a problem tree and can be created by rephrasing each of the problems into desirable outcomes, this way the root causes and. Each problem is preceded by the problem s which causes it, and followed by the problem it causes itself, see figure 1. Problem tree analysis helps stakeholders to establish a realistic overview and awareness of the problem by ing the fundamental causes and their most identify important effects. The analysis is structured so that cause and effect are laid out visually, showing linkages between different factors. Brainstorm all problems related to malnutrition for your specific livelihood group 2. Historical background of problem and objective trees.
Find the causes and effects to the focal problem the causes of the problem shall be tackled through activities within the framework of the project in order to solve the problem in a. The problem tree is one method of mapping out core problems, along with their causes and effects, helping project planners to identify clear and manageable objectives. Objective analysis tree is is a project planning tool that helps to analyze and graphically break down objectives into smaller and more manageable parts the objective analysis tree is a tool derived from its parent tool the problem analysis tree. The main output of the exercise is a tree shaped diagram in which the trunk represents the focal problem, the roots. The negative situations identified in the problem tree are transformed into positive and already reached situations. What is and how to make a problem tree issue tree season 6 ep 4. The problem tree gives no indication of the magnitude of the problem. The third objective was to use fault tree analysis to study the. Problem tree analysis effects focal problem causes problem tree analysis is best carried out in a small focus group of about six to eight people using flip chart paper or an overhead transparency.
It is a participatory planning method that helps to establish cause and effect between the various layers of the overall problem being addressed. What is a malnutrition problem tree a tool to systematically analyze the causes of malnutrition problems. Using problem and objective tree for community development. Each of the subunits of the objective tree can represent an alternative strategy for the future project. Step up training materials glasgow learning network. The problem tree method is a planning method based on needs, however it is not a mechanical translation of problems into objectives. Objective tree overall objectives project purpose results problem tree effects focal problem. Seven management and planning tools quality mind map. The problem tree is transformed into an objectives tree by restating the. The problem tree moves top downwards, identifying first the major problem, then the factors that determine these problems and then the causes of these factors. This tool is used in conjunction with other project planning tools, objectives tree and strategy analysis they often follow the problem tree analysis.
Objectives analysis an objectives analysis in a wide sense is a procedure for systematically identifying, categorising, specifying and if required balancing out objectives of all parties involved in a specific situation for which those objectives apply. While the problem analysis tree is used for analyzing the current situation or a present problem, the. You can also use this exercise to explain to staff members how to identify analyze problems and set up objectives. A problem tree is a useful tool for analyzing a situation. A problem analysis workshop consist of a 4 step process. When the problem has been fully analyzed, the design team may find it useful to construct an objective tree that reframes the central problem and its causes as changes or results to be achieved. Nov 02, 2011 the processa problem tree is best completed with theproject proponent and other stakeholderspresent. Swot analysis for a community capacitybuilding strategy 26 figure 10. The problem tree should be developed as a participatory group activity. This enables a clearer prioritisation of factors and helps focus objectives.
You cannot always directly translate problems into objectives. Objectives analysis an objectivesanalysis in a wide sense is a procedure for systematically identifying, categorising, specifying and if required balancing out objectives of all parties involved in a specific situation for which those objectives apply. The objective tree moves bottom upwards, first identifying the outputs that would directly address the causes of the factors and then identifying the specific objectives that directly. The process of analysis can often help build a shared sense of understanding, purpose and action.
The problem tree helps you think of a problem in a thorough manner and provides a structured way to analyze it. Problem tree managing for sustainable development impact. The problem tree is a useful tool for analyzing a problem with all its causes, effects and factors. One varies numbers and sees the effect one can also look for changes in the data that. But the tree is only the beginning typically in decision trees, there is a great deal of uncertainty surrounding the numbers. Social, cultural, economic and religious dimensions of hiv and aids hiv and aids instruction. Development cooperation handbookdesigning and executing. A best practice to carry out a problem analysis tree exercise is to gather a focus group of 510 people and stress the teamwork during the problem setting, problem analysis and objective setting.
548 453 755 649 907 919 1387 1031 1286 524 26 1521 679 1100 915 1284 1090 583 1160 484 961 416 692 1053 898 75 656 1019 1278 469 1433 1322 1311 427 762 1266 34 1320 1227 302